| Additive or group | Typical use | Evidence and regulatory status | Planning use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Red 3 | Food dye | The FDA determined in 1990 that it causes cancer in animals, and it remained permitted in food more than three decades later | Strongest concern in this table. Choose another product when it appears on the ingredient list. |
| Synthetic dyes as a group | Food colouring | California concluded in 2021 that synthetic dyes can cause or worsen neurobehavioral problems in some children | Cut back first for children, especially where behaviour or attention is already a concern. |
| Tartrazine (102), sunset yellow FCF (110), yellow 2G (107) | Food colourings (Australian codes) | May cause problems for some people | Relevant if you suspect a personal reaction. Track these by name or code on labels. |
| Self-declared GRAS substances | Intentionally added ingredients of many kinds | Companies can declare a substance GRAS and use it without notifying the FDA, as CSPI describes | The status is not a verdict either way. Judge the specific ingredient, not the acronym. |
Ratings and statuses above come from the Center for Science in the Public Interest’s additive ratings and the Better Health Channel’s food additives page.
The food additives to avoid first are those with a regulator-recognised or well-documented concern, not every unfamiliar ingredient. Red 3 and synthetic dyes lead the list, while most other additives call for label checks rather than blanket avoidance.
Ranking by evidence also keeps shopping practical. Our healthy eating guidelines show how additive choices fit into the wider pattern of everyday eating.
Ranking additives by strength of evidence
A scare list treats every additive alike. An evidence ranking separates additives that regulators or reviewers have flagged from those that matter only to some people. The Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) rates additives on a five-level scale: Safe, Cut back, Certain people should avoid, Caution and Avoid. Its Avoid rating is reserved for an additive that poses serious risk or is strongly linked to serious harm, and the ratings draw on toxicological, epidemiological and exposure data from the peer-reviewed literature.
CSPI also draws a useful line between chemicals that only people with sensitivities or intolerances need to avoid and those everyone should reduce. The Better Health Channel makes a similar point for Australia: 50 of the 400 currently approved additives have been associated with adverse reactions in some people. Only a minority of approved additives are therefore flagged at all, which is why a targeted approach works better than avoiding everything with an unfamiliar name.
That ranking translates into four practical decisions:
- Act first on regulator-recognised findings. Red 3 belongs here, because a federal agency itself reached a cancer finding in animals.
- Reduce rather than eliminate where the evidence concerns susceptible groups. Synthetic dyes and children fit this pattern, so households with children gain the most from cutting back.
- Match avoidance to your own reactions. Colourings linked to problems in some people only need to be avoided by those who react.
- Treat regulatory status as a starting point. Whether an ingredient is approved or declared GRAS describes its route to market, not a guarantee about your exposure.
The strongest cases are worth looking at one by one.
Additives with the strongest evidence of harm
Red 3
The FDA determined in 1990 that the food dye Red 3 causes cancer in animals, and CSPI notes it was still allowed in food more than three decades later. The gap between a regulatory finding and a regulatory outcome is the main lesson. Its presence on a supermarket shelf tells you little about how strong the evidence is, so the ingredient list is the better guide.
The finding comes from animal studies, which supports avoidance as a precaution rather than as proof of a measured human risk. The practical step is simple: look for Red 3 in the ingredient list and choose another product when it appears.
Synthetic dyes and children
Harvard Health, summarising American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) policy, reports that artificial food colours have been found to increase symptoms in children who have attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. That summary describes an association and gives no effect size. California went further in 2021, concluding that synthetic dyes can cause or worsen neurobehavioral problems in some children, as CSPI reports.
The wording matters: “some children” does not mean every child. If you have a child with attention or behaviour difficulties, dyes are a sensible first change to try, because the supporting evidence points at that group. For other children and adults, cutting back is a reasonable precaution, not an urgent correction.
Colourings that affect sensitive people
The Better Health Channel lists tartrazine 102, sunset yellow FCF 110 and yellow 2G 107 among food colourings that may cause problems for some people. Those numbers are Australian additive codes, and the same colourings may appear under names on other labels. This is a sensitivity issue, not a population-wide warning, so it matters most to anyone who suspects that particular foods trigger their symptoms.
What regulatory status does and does not tell you
The FDA treats intentionally added substances as food additives that are subject to premarket review and approval, unless they are generally recognized as safe (GRAS). Two routes to GRAS are described in the same guidance. A substance can qualify through scientific procedures, which requires the same quantity and quality of scientific evidence as additive approval under 21 CFR 170.30(b). It can also qualify for a substance used in food before 1958 through experience based on common use. The eligibility rules are set out in 21 CFR 170.30.
Those two routes mean the same acronym can stand for rigorous testing or for a long history of use. The difference matters when you are weighing a label, because history of use is a different kind of assurance from a modern evidence package.
CSPI adds a further caution: companies can declare a substance GRAS and use it without notifying the FDA. A self-declared use may therefore never have been reviewed by the agency at all. The FDA has since moved on this. On August 10, 2026, it proposed a rule to enhance oversight of GRAS uses (docket FDA-2025-N-3262), according to its GRAS page. Until oversight changes in practice, treat “GRAS” as a description of how an ingredient reached the market and judge the individual ingredient on its own evidence.
Finding additives on labels
Label reading is the working tool for everything above, and the Better Health Channel’s description of Australian labelling shows what to look for.
- Order tells you quantity. Most additives are listed with the other ingredients in descending order by weight, so an additive near the end is present in a smaller amount than ingredients near the start.
- Codes can replace names. An additive may appear as a number, for example cochineal as Colouring (120) or sodium sulphite as Preservative (221). Keep the codes for any colouring you want to avoid, such as 102, 107 and 110, in your phone notes.
- Flavours are an exception. The weight-order rule does not apply to flavours, so a flavour entry cannot tell you what it contains.
- Compound ingredients can hide additives. Some listed ingredients contain additives without naming them. The Better Health Channel gives margarine as an example, so a short ingredient list is not proof that nothing else is in the product.
The Better Health Channel guidance describes Australian rules, so use the codes as search terms and rely on the names printed on your own market’s labels. Searching for the dye names from the table is the quickest way to apply the evidence ranking in the aisle.
Simple swaps that cut additive exposure
Swaps work best when they replace a whole product type rather than hunting for a cleaner version of the same item. The AAP advice summarised by Harvard Health is to buy and serve more fresh or frozen fruits and vegetables, and fewer processed meats, especially during pregnancy. Frozen produce counts, which keeps this affordable and practical for busy households.

Whole fruit is the natural replacement for coloured sweets, since dyes are the strongest additive concern in this guide for children. Choosing fruit removes the colouring question for that snack entirely, with no label to decode.

The same AAP advice suggests using more glass and stainless steel instead of plastic for food containers, which is an easy change when you replace storage ware. When cooking fats are the concern rather than additives, our guide Seed Oils To Avoid: A Practical Guide To Healthier Cooking Fats In 2026 – Testpledge covers that decision separately.
Rebuilding meals around fresh food also raises the question of what are macronutrients and how much of each a balanced plate needs, which is worth settling before you overhaul the weekly shop.
Frequently asked questions
Can I work out an additive sensitivity myself?
Not reliably. The Better Health Channel says diagnosing sensitivity to food additives needs professional help, because the symptoms can have other causes. Keep a note of what you ate and what you reacted to, and take it to a health professional.
Does processed food always contain additives?
No. Long-life milk, canned foods and frozen foods are all processed, yet none of them need extra chemicals, according to the Better Health Channel. Judge the ingredient list, not the word “processed”.
Are the combined effects of several additives known?
No. The Better Health Channel states that the long-term effects of consuming a combination of different additives are currently unknown. That is one reason to favour products with fewer additives rather than relying on any single additive’s rating.
Is there a safety margin built into additive approval?
In Australia, the Better Health Channel says the permitted intake is usually an amount 100 times less than the maximum daily dose that showed no observable effects in animals. That describes the Australian approval process, and it does not cover additives that are the subject of later findings.



